What should be the basis for assessing a page's quality?

A page's quality should be primarily assessed based on how well it achieves its intended purpose. This means evaluating whether the content effectively meets the needs and expectations of its intended audience. For instance, if a page is designed to provide information, its quality would be determined by the accuracy, depth, and relevance of that information to the users looking for it.

Focusing on a page's intended purpose ensures that the evaluation aligns with user experience and satisfaction. This approach considers not only the content provided but also how well the page engages its target audience, guiding them to the information they are seeking or facilitating their specific tasks.

While visual appeal, advertising accuracy, and the number of links can contribute to a page's overall quality, they are secondary to the core function of the page. A visually appealing design may enhance user engagement, but if the content does not fulfill its purpose, it ultimately falls short on quality. Similarly, accurate advertising and external links can add value, but they do not replace the necessity for the page to effectively deliver on what it promises to its users.